• Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Disclaimer
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
Sixsense News
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Fintech
  • Finance
  • Insurance
  • Market
  • Startups
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Fintech
  • Finance
  • Insurance
  • Market
  • Startups
No Result
View All Result
Sixsense News
No Result
View All Result
Home Economy

Jacob Soll’s “free market” – Econlib

Sixsense News by Sixsense News
October 4, 2022
in Economy
0


In the City Journal, I have reviewed Jacob Soll’s new book, Free Market: The History of an Idea.

Books arguing that “free market thought fails to account for periodic and devastating market failure,” or claiming that Milton Friedman stood for “libertarian corporate social-Darwinism” and rebuking him for his supposed affinity for Augusto Pinochet’s Chile, are not in short supply. That modern free-market economists were “crusading Cold War warriors with little patience for nuance or for contradictions in their own thought” is a ritornello of many scholars. …

Yet Jacob Soll is smarter than his many competitors. His Free Market: The History of an Idea starts with Cicero and doesn’t get to Friedman until page 250. Soll enlists the wisdom of the ancients and 2,000 years of history in his battle—the enemy being, in this case, the idea of a deregulated economy, in which the government is severely limited. Soll refrains from using pejoratives like “neo-liberalism” and refers instead to the “free market.” Such chivalry—calling his adversaries what they would like to be called—is commendable. Still, a clearer definition of “free-market thought” and an explanation for his use of this expression would have been helpful in a broadside against individualism or capitalism.

Soll is certainly more learned (and more interesting, when he speaks of things he actually studied and pondered) than your average critic of “neoliberalism” and, thank God, doesn’t use that word. Still the book is disappointing. Barton Swaim wrote a powerful review for the Wall Street Journal, a few days ago. Professor Soll replied to that explaining that “my critiques of free-market thinkers aren’t made in bad faith. I admire Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman and treasure individual liberties and economic freedoms. I simply remain perplexed that subsequent leaders dedicated to such ideas supported alliances with segregationists, whose ideas were the stark opposite of universal libertarianism”.

I did not touch the point of that juxtaposition in my review, thinking that was just derivative, in Soll’s work, from his wider worldview. Note that even in Swaim’s excellent article this is merely tangential, whereas he aptly points out that “for Mr. Soll’s book to work—and this is true of many such books by economists, pundits and historians of the political left—he has to pretend that the free marketeers have basically run the show for the past 70 years”. So, Soll’s reply (though of course circumscribed by the needs of brevity) focuses on scoring a rhetorical point rather than addressing a substantial issue. It didn’t make me think higher of him .



Source link

Related articles

Sri Lanka ready to engage with all creditors after IMF deal

March 21, 2023

2:00PM Water Cooler 3/21/2023 | naked capitalism

March 21, 2023
Tags: EconlibFreeJacobmarketSolls

Related Posts

Sri Lanka ready to engage with all creditors after IMF deal

by Reuters
March 21, 2023
0

© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: People sit on their empty cylinders as they wait in a queue to buy domestic gas...

2:00PM Water Cooler 3/21/2023 | naked capitalism

by Lambert Strether
March 21, 2023
0

By Lambert Strether of Corrente. Bird Song of the Day Wood Thrush, Lander, MD. C&O canal at Lander, Frederick, Maryland,...

Yellen vows to safeguard deposits at smaller U.S. banks, intervene if needed By Reuters

by Reuters
March 21, 2023
0

© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen takes questions on the Biden administration's plans following the collapse of...

ECB tells banks to watch their cash amid turmoil By Reuters

by Reuters
March 21, 2023
0

© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: Andrea Enria, chairperson of the European Banking Authority, speaks at Reuters Summit interview in London, Britain,...

Streaming boosts recorded music revenue, China market growing By Reuters

by Reuters
March 21, 2023
0

2/2 © Reuters. FILE PHOTO: A customer listens to music in a store in Los Angeles, California, U.S., June 24,...

Load More

Best Stock Screeners to Enhance Your Trades

March 21, 2023

*HOT* Amazon Fire HD 10″ 32GB Tablet only $69.99 shipped (Reg. $150!)

March 21, 2023

TechCrunch+ roundup: Big Data’s cloud backlash, CVC pitch tips, de-risking hardware startups

March 21, 2023

Amazon, Target pick up Bed Bath & Beyond’s lost market share – BofA (NASDAQ:BBBY)

March 21, 2023

Biden’s first veto preserves 401(k) investment rule about ESG funds

March 21, 2023

Toro Company Declares $0.34 Quarterly Dividend; 1.2% Yield By Investing.com

March 21, 2023
Sixsense News

© 2022 Sixsense News All Rights Reserved.

Navigate Site

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Disclaimer
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • #3158 (no title)
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Finance
  • Fintech
  • Insurance
  • Market
  • Startups

© 2022 Sixsense News All Rights Reserved.